Posted: Thu Jul 20, 2006 9:35 pm
Since it seems like a tie, it's up to me to...not tip it in one way or another. Nobody can predict exactly how such a change will turn out, which is why I don't feel obliged to support any side of the argument, but I think we should clearly weigh the advantages and disadvantages.
Pro--possibly more activity, central board is more convenient for people who are active everywhere like Duxburian, and it will encourage a wider range of viewing for people like me and joannaardway.
Cons--possibly less stability in the long run and uncertainty even in the near future, will mean a large change, and the merging of opinions from different forums might start a fatal clash.
Obviously, I only really hang out here at SSC--it's been a while since I've visited SM and even longer since I posted at iScF [although I get the feeling that Duxburian started similar topics at those sites]. I'm comfortable here, but such a change is something that I wouldn't oppose if it happened. I do support a more central atmosphere, but it would have to be well executed. Naturally, since I wasn't at Aquatica and more importantly since I only hear of the bad news, I have no clue about this.
Already, much change has been, is, or will be going on at the main sites (in other words, not at the forums) of SM and SSC. Will these have a dramatic effect on the current generation of forums? And more importantly, can future projects such as the SSC Store reel in more members and create a base that will keep a central forum very active (though needless to say, none of the current forums are tremendously active)?
I can't offer that much of an opinion yet, but if this does happen, I'll be one of the strongest supporters. Maybe there should be a "branching" site, kind of like a combination of a central site and NiborDude's directory. You'd have one massively central page with the news and forums maybe, and then individuals could have their own "corners"--like an SM tactics page, more personal ones like m15399's site, and others to add more "flavor" to the entire site. Hopefully, having the forums in the main site would keep the activity central.
Pro--possibly more activity, central board is more convenient for people who are active everywhere like Duxburian, and it will encourage a wider range of viewing for people like me and joannaardway.
Cons--possibly less stability in the long run and uncertainty even in the near future, will mean a large change, and the merging of opinions from different forums might start a fatal clash.
Obviously, I only really hang out here at SSC--it's been a while since I've visited SM and even longer since I posted at iScF [although I get the feeling that Duxburian started similar topics at those sites]. I'm comfortable here, but such a change is something that I wouldn't oppose if it happened. I do support a more central atmosphere, but it would have to be well executed. Naturally, since I wasn't at Aquatica and more importantly since I only hear of the bad news, I have no clue about this.
Already, much change has been, is, or will be going on at the main sites (in other words, not at the forums) of SM and SSC. Will these have a dramatic effect on the current generation of forums? And more importantly, can future projects such as the SSC Store reel in more members and create a base that will keep a central forum very active (though needless to say, none of the current forums are tremendously active)?
I can't offer that much of an opinion yet, but if this does happen, I'll be one of the strongest supporters. Maybe there should be a "branching" site, kind of like a combination of a central site and NiborDude's directory. You'd have one massively central page with the news and forums maybe, and then individuals could have their own "corners"--like an SM tactics page, more personal ones like m15399's site, and others to add more "flavor" to the entire site. Hopefully, having the forums in the main site would keep the activity central.